matlab solve 结果不正确,怎么办啊???????

syms Y a b c d u
[a,b,c,d,u]=dsolve('-1=18*a*b+3*u','13=18*a+18*a*c+18*(1-a)*b-9*u','-11=18*a*d+18*c-18*a*c-18*a+9*u','1=18*a*d-18*d+3*u','0=b+c+d','a,b,c,d,u')
syms Y a b c d u
[a,b,c,d,u]=solve('-1=18*a*b+3*u','13=18*a+18*a*c+18*(1-a)*b-9*u','-11=18*a*d+18*c-18*a*c-18*a+9*u','1=18*a*d-18*d+3*u','0=b+c+d','a,b,c,d,u')
计算不出正确, 结果啊,在线等,急!!!!!!!!!!!

非常感谢谢回答啊!!!!!!!!
对 化学工程 - 首席运营官的答案:
clc;clear
syms Y a b c d u
f1=18*a*b+3*u+1
f2=18*a+18*a*c+18*(1-a)*b-9*u-13
f3=18*a*d+18*c-18*a*c-18*a+9*u+11
f4=18*a*d-18*d+3*u-1
f5=b+c+d
ff=simple(f4-f1-f2-f3)
[a,b,c,d,u]=solve(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5)
[bb,cc,dd,uu]=solve(f1,f2,f3,f4,'b,c,d,u')

怎么没有人理我啊???????????????????
怎么没有人理我啊???????????????????
怎么没有人理我啊???????????????????

“ luoshenglai”的答案和“化学工程”的答案是一样的啦,不正确啊!!
因为按道理,把结果代入f1、f2、f3、f4、f5应该全都是0

找到了!前4个方程可以组合成第5个非常,实际上只有4个方程,第5个方程多余。

clc;clear
syms Y a b c d u
f1=18*a*b+3*u+1
f2=18*a+18*a*c+18*(1-a)*b-9*u-13
f3=18*a*d+18*c-18*a*c-18*a+9*u+11
f4=18*a*d-18*d+3*u-1
f5=b+c+d
ff=simple(f4-f1-f2-f3)
[a,b,c,d,u]=solve(f1,f2,f3,f4,f5)
[bb,cc,dd,uu]=solve(f1,f2,f3,f4,'b,c,d,u')

结果:
f5 =

b+c+d

ff =

-18*d-18*b-18*c

a =

a

b =

-5/3*a+5/9+a^2

c =

7/3*a-4/9-2*a^2

d =

-2/3*a-1/9+a^2

u =

-1/3+10*a^2-10/3*a-6*a^3

bb =

-5/3*a+5/9+a^2

cc =

7/3*a-4/9-2*a^2

dd =

-2/3*a-1/9+a^2

uu =

-1/3+10*a^2-10/3*a-6*a^3
温馨提示:答案为网友推荐,仅供参考
第1个回答  2009-06-27
f1 =

18*a*b+3*u+1

f2 =

18*a+18*a*c+(18-18*a)*b-9*u-13

f3 =

18*a*d+18*c-18*a*c-18*a+9*u+11

f4 =

18*a*d-18*d+3*u-1

f5 =

b+c+d

ff =

-18*d-18*b-18*c

a =

a

b =

5/9-5/3*a+a^2

c =

-4/9+7/3*a-2*a^2

d =

-1/9-2/3*a+a^2

u =

-10/3*a+10*a^2-6*a^3-1/3

bb =

5/9-5/3*a+a^2

cc =

-4/9+7/3*a-2*a^2

dd =

-1/9-2/3*a+a^2

uu =

-10/3*a+10*a^2-6*a^3-1/3
第2个回答  2009-06-14
a =

-(3*z + 54*(((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - ((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27)^2 + (12*((2*z)/27 - 22/729))/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 12*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 17/9)/(9*z - 3)
-(3*z - (6*((2*z)/27 - 22/729))/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 54*(((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/(2*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)) - ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)/2 - (3^(1/2)*i*(((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)))/2 + 2/27)^2 + 6*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 6*3^(1/2)*i*(((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)) - 17/9)/(9*z - 3)
-(3*z - (6*((2*z)/27 - 22/729))/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 54*(((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/(2*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)) - ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)/2 + (3^(1/2)*i*(((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)))/2 + 2/27)^2 + 6*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 6*3^(1/2)*i*(((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)) - 17/9)/(9*z - 3)

b =

(3*z + 18*(((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - ((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27)^2 + (5*((2*z)/27 - 22/729))/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 3*z*(((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - ((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27) - 5*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 37/27)/(3*z - 1)
1/(3*z - 1)*(3*z + 18*(1/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 1/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27 - 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*1/2*I)^2 - 5/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 3*z*(1/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 1/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27 - 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*1/2*I) + 5/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 37/27 + 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*5/2*I)
1/(3*z - 1)*(3*z + 18*(1/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 1/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27 + 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*1/2*I)^2 - 5/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 3*z*(1/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 1/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27 + 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*1/2*I) + 5/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 37/27 - 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*5/2*I)

c =

-(3*z + 18*(((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - ((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27)^2 + (6*((2*z)/27 - 22/729))/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 6*z*(((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - ((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27) - 6*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 13/9)/(3*z - 1)
-1/(3*z - 1)*(3*z + 18*(1/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 1/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27 - 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*1/2*I)^2 - 3*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 6*z*(1/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 1/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27 - 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*1/2*I) + 3*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 13/9 + 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*3*I)
-1/(3*z - 1)*(3*z + 18*(1/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 1/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27 + 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*1/2*I)^2 - 3*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 6*z*(1/2*(2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 1/2*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27 + 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*1/2*I) + 3*(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - 13/9 - 3^(1/2)*((2/27*z - 22/729)/(((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + (((2/27*z - 22/729)^3 + (1/72*z^2 - 17/972*z + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - 17/972*z + 1/72*z^2 + 739/157464)^(1/3))*3*I)

d =

((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) - ((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + 2/27
((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/(2*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)) - ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)/2 - (3^(1/2)*i*(((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)))/2 + 2/27
((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/(2*((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)) - ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)/2 + (3^(1/2)*i*(((2*z)/27 - 22/729)/((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3) + ((((2*z)/27 - 22/729)^3 + (z^2/72 - (17*z)/972 + 739/157464)^2)^(1/2) - (17*z)/972 + z^2/72 + 739/157464)^(1/3)))/2 + 2/27

u =

z
z
z
相似回答