请教一道英语语法题（关于名词性物主代词和形容词性物主代词的）

Question

请教一道英语语法题
Whose is this/that...? This/That is my/your/his/her...
为什么不能为
Whose is this/that...? This/That is mine/yours/his/hers...
为什么不用名词性物主代词呢？

Answer 1

正确的是：
Whose is this/that...? This/That is mine/yours/his/hers...
如
Whose is that book?
It's mine/ yours / his /hers .

*****************************************************************************
祝天天开心，学习进步！本题不明白，请再问；
如果对你有所帮助，请点击本页面中的“选为满意回答”按钮,谢谢！
*****************************************************************************追问

非常感谢您的回答，可是新概念一册上是这么写的呀，请问大神，新概念错了吗？（那个，别误会，我只是想确认一下）谢谢谢谢谢谢(*^__^*) 嘻嘻……

追答

Whose is this/that...? This/That is my/your/his/her... 这种回答是错的， 应该用名词性物主代词； 因为形容词性物主代词在句中不能单独出现，它们后面要接名词。

追问

谢谢，但是如果是第三人称单数的话，如：
Whose handbag is this? It's Stella's.和Whose handbag is this? It's Stella's.handbag.请问大师有区别吗，如果有，区别又在哪儿呢？

追答

没有区别，但一般用第一句（ 为了避免重复）

注：Stella's = Stlla's handbad

要弄清名词所有格与形容词性物主代词不同呀

Whose handbag is this? It's Stella's.和Whose handbag is this? It's Stella's handbag. 都对（ 建议采纳第一种）

Whose is this/that...? This/That is my/your/his/her... 是错的。

Whose is this/that...? This/That is mine/yours/his/hers... 正确

Answer 2

mine/yours/his/hers 的意思是我自己的/你自己的/他/她自己的。

my/your/his/her...后需要接一个名词。。追问

谢谢，但如果是第三人称单数的话，如
Whose is this handbag? It's Stella's. 和 Whose is this handbag? It's Stella's handbag.请问学神有区别吗？区别在哪儿呢？

追答

没有区别。Whose is this handbag? It's Stella's. 和It's Stella's handbag. 这句话如果真要找区别的话那就是前句精简明了，后句重复啰嗦